Up 20%, then 20% off: why the price doesn't go back

Arif Acar ·

Short answer: the two percentages are taken from different amounts. The increase is 20% of the old price, and the discount is 20% of the higher, new price. The discount is the bigger of the two, so the price ends up below where it started.

An example

A product costs $1,250 and goes up 20%. 20% of 1,250 is $250, so the new price is $1,500.

A few weeks later the store runs a "20% off" sale. This time 20% is taken from $1,500, which is $300. The price drops to $1,200, which is $50 less than before the increase.

1,250 × 1.20 × 0.80 = $1,200

The order makes no difference. A 20% cut followed by a 20% rise gives 1,250 × 0.80 × 1.20, which is also $1,200, because multiplication doesn't care about order.

How much do you lose?

An increase and a decrease of the same percentage always end below the starting value. The loss is the square of the rate:

(1 + p) × (1 − p) = 1 − p²

For 20%, p² = 0.04, a 4% loss. And 4% of $1,250 is exactly $50. The gap grows quickly as the rate goes up:

RateAfter the rise and the cutLoss
10%99%1%
20%96%4%
30%91%9%
50%75%25%

The discount that undoes an increase

A seller who wants to bring the price back to exactly where it was needs a discount smaller than 20%:

Discount needed = r ÷ (1 + r)
IncreaseDiscount back to the old price
10%9.09%
20%16.67%
25%20%
50%33.33%
100%50%

The rise that makes up for a drop

In the other direction the numbers flip. Something that loses 20% has to gain 25% to get back to its old value:

Rise needed = d ÷ (1 − d)
DropRise needed to recover
10%11.11%
20%25%
30%42.86%
50%100%

Investors run into this all the time. A stock that loses half its value has to double just to break even.

Where you'll see it

  • Price tags raised before a sale and then marked "30% off". Compare the sale price with the price before the increase.
  • A fund that falls 50% one year and rises 50% the next ends 25% below where it began.
  • Taking VAT out of a price. In a country with 20% VAT, a price of 1,200 including VAT is 1,200 ÷ 1.20 = 1,000 before tax. Knocking 20% off gives 960, which is wrong.

Working it out in Calcify

The percentage calculator has "change from A to B" and "A increased or decreased by B%" modes that do these sums in one step. If you know the tag price and the discount, the discount calculator shows what you pay and how much you save. To take VAT out of a gross price, use the VAT calculator.